What's new
Aloft Forums

Welcome to Aloft Forums. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Trouble shooting failing elevator servo

WillS

New User
I've had my elevator servo become unresponsive twice. First time it failed after several great flight. I repaired the plane and replaced the servo and the extension cable. Flew great for a few batteries, then lost elevator. Is it possible there is an issue with my RX6R channel 3? I have about 10 planes running an assortment of Frsky rx6r, 4r and 8r and never had an issue with any of them.

Stats:
Taranis XD9 + 2019 SE running RF v1. Haven't moved to v2. Is this an potential concern?
RX6R
Added a capacitor to the rx to prevent brown outs
30A ESC w/ 3A BEC. Motor draws 18Amps (same setup as on several of my planes...)
4 - 9g servos

My plan is to replace the Rx and the ESC with a larger 5A BEC (basically swapped out everything but the plane), but Id like to hear from others on what could have caused 2 different servos to intermittently failures.

Thanks,
Will
 
Wow, how large is the cap if it is bing used to power the servos during power transient spikes? Most caps are too small, they are usually used a noise filter. As a back up power supply to prevent brown out they would have to be rather large to hold any real energy (Joules). Remember servos need energy to produce work.

Wow, a 3 Amp linear BEC is marginal for 4 servos. Way under powered if any are digital servos.
What size battery? With a 2 cell you might get away with it. 3 cells is the upper limit for a linear BEC. And 4 cell is the making of a burning hole in the ground.

An underrated power supply can allow the servos to stall prematurely allowing the motors to heat up and fail. Is the control surface and linkage free for the range of motion? No binds at either extreme end of motion.
 
Konrad.. Maybe Im using the wrong term.. I added one of those capacity thingies (HobbyEagle 16V EZ-Plug Capacitor). Heard they help with potential issues.. Maybe it was snake-oil...

3S 2200mah battery. Similar setup as several planes that haven't had issues... The control surface is totally free from any issues...

I'm learning a great deal about the power requirements needed for the servos.. I always read that you need .5A per servo.. Is sounds like your rule of thumb is about 1A per servo... I assume it depends on the size of the servos.. right?

I just swapped out all other servo extensions, a new Rx and a ESC with 5A BEC. I'm testing it out tomorrow...
 
Snake oil maybe. Caps can make the voltage input a bit smoother. But to think that they can cover up a hole in the voltage for any length of time (like 3 mil sec) from say the draw of 4 servos is often beyond their abilities.

I try to not use rules of thumbs when it comes to power. I like to use actual measurements if possible. As counter intuitive as it may seem I often see micro servos drawing more current that their larger brethren. Are you using digital or analog servos?

If these are linear BEC then 4 servo of of a large 3 cell lipo could be putting the BEC up against its thermal limit.

What are the concerns with the servo extensions, poor contacts?

I try to avoid linear BEC. If I'm forced to use than I try to give it a lot of cooling air. Remember that the BEC has to she d the heat as a function of (Vss - Vreg) x total current draw.
 
Konrad,

Analog servos are used.. The servos in this plane are the cheapo Miuzei SG90 servos from Amazon. I've used dozens for my FT foamboard plans... (I usually build a plane a week or two, My friends are happy since I keep them flying)

Its funny, I've been building and flying a long time 25+ years. I just recently got back into the hobby and I've been going nuts with building and upgrading plane. (brushed to brushless, new lipo, rx and escs. I switched from 72mhz radio to the Taranis in Sept 20. So, with that said... Not sure if the BEC is linear or not.. I have a lot to learn about ESC/BECs

Servo Ext swap? Just trying to eliminate potential issues/RF noise or whatever.. I'm not a super technical guy.. Need to learn..

So it sounds like the cause of my two servo failures is the BEC not delivering enough to channel 3 on the rx.. The frustration is I've used this setup on numerous planes without issue.... Sounds like I'm lucky.... kinda.....

What are your recommendations for ESCs for 5-5 9g servos, Motors drawing 15-25A. I came from a mentally of build it light too..
 
Last edited:
Konrad,
Flew a few times this am.. No issues other than a significant jittering of servos when I placed the wing on the plane (spitfire)... Pulled the wing off and the jittering stopped... Ended up keeping the aileron wires outside the fuse and no jittering.. I'm at a loss.. Maybe this plane is cursed...

Just for the heck of it, Im going to upgrade the TX RF to v2x.. (along with the fleet of rx....)

Appreciate the feedback..

Will
 
Jittering is usually noise on the servo lead. Twisted leads often cancel this out. This has become more of an issue with the advent of telemetry as the RX is now a source of radiant energy.

What refresh frame rate are you using? With your analog servos you want to be using something like 19ms not the fast 9ms used for digital servos.
 
Refresh rate??? You are blowing my mind.. Are you Elec Engineer that grew-up building Heathkits as a kid???? :)

I'm lucky to just get my new fangled TX to bind with the RX.. I'll look up the refresh rate and let you know what I got...

btw, appreciate the coaching..

Will
 
FS Mode.

I added the twisted cables. It appears to help a bit.. Still something going on...

Question.. Does the RF v2.1 upgrade sound like it can be a fix? I'm currently at 1.1.0/1.1.3 FCC...
 
Sort of, I built an Ace Silver Seven and various analog mixing boards.

While I strongly recommend upgrading to ACCST v2.1.xx it will not address your short servo life issues.
 
yep...
We ruled out the servo and the extension. (replaced with same results). It flew today without mishap after I replaced the ESC and RX. I'm going in install the suspect parts in a more disposable plane and try it out.. Then replace the esc and see again.. Why not... right?
Any chance the rx was bad?
Does a maxed out BEC usually fail the whole system or just one channel?
 
yep...
We ruled out the servo and the extension. (replaced with same results). It flew today without mishap after I replaced the ESC and RX. I'm going in install the suspect parts in a more disposable plane and try it out.. Then replace the esc and see again.. Why not... right?
Any chance the rx was bad? YES, but highly unlikely.
Does a maxed out BEC usually fail the whole system or just one channel? Hard to say, normally the failure is the power components (servos). Not sure what you are asking. But as the servo power bus is of a common architecture, if the other servos are working then I don't think there is an issue with RX electrical bus.
All the best,
Konrad
 
Last edited:
A 3amp Bec is risky at the best of times especially one located in the ESC. I would upgrade to a good quality 5 amp Bec. Not a Chinese type as they often over rate the output without specifying the voltage drop when drawing current. If there is a voltage drop from the Bec that causes a servo to stop working it most likely will cause the receiver to shut down for a brief period as well.

Don't skimp on power components it's not worth crashing a model.
 
Thanks Konrad...

Henny, I've been doing a bit of reading about BECs.. Funny thing, I've been flying for quite some time with ESCs/BEC 2-3A and 3-4 servos without issues. Some of my mini 24" Balsa conversions have 3-4 5g servos and are using 1A BEC without failure.. That said, I think I've been lucky... It would be prudent for some BECs on my special planes and bump up my esc/bec options...
 
Cooling is key. So is the refresh rate. If you have by accident set up the radio to have the 9ms rate with analog servos and a weak BEC, you have better odds playing Russian roulette!
 
Well, it failed again today.... I've swapped out the Elev-Servo, ESC/BEC (new one has 5A), RX and servo extensions. Not sure what else would continue to cause the elevator to fail.. I have many planes that are flown weekly with no issues like this. All have same type RX, Same TX, similar binding process and so on... The mechanic on the elevator are solid. No binding, servo in rear of plane, 4" from tail, so no flexing of the control rod.. She'll fly fine for a few days, then fail......

The plane is fixable, but I think its cursed... I was thinking about deleting the model from the radio, Scrapping the whole plane and starting over with new parts..

Konrad, not sure how I can accidentally setup my radio for the 9ms rates. I've tried to dig into this and see that is set during binding.. I don't use jumpers on the rx, so, not sure how I can screw it up... But I've been known to do stupid stuff....
 
Hold it up to the forum and let us take a look! Maybe it is time for some videos, we might see something you are missing. Also maybe it is time to upgrade the servo, the Tower Pro SG90 (Analog or digital) are entry level servos. I suspect there is more load on this servo than you think, linkage drag, hinges, or air load.

Heck a $1.80 servo, these aren't even Tower Pro ! Really, you expect any quality?
 
Last edited:
Konrad, I get it.. They are cheap, I expect some failures.. However the dozen cheap FT Foam planes are using the same servos with ZERO issues.. So, I can't believe that 2 bad servos out of the 30+ I'm using, happen to fail on the same plane.. Seems like some crazy odds.. But heck if I know... Thats why I'm asking the forum..

Not sure if the pictures are going to show anything... I attached power and of course the elevator worked great...

So, the answer is most likely bad luck on cheap servos selection?????
 

Attachments

  • IMG_6720.jpg
    IMG_6720.jpg
    59.1 KB · Views: 183
  • IMG_6719.jpg
    IMG_6719.jpg
    80.2 KB · Views: 195
Back
Top