What's new
Aloft Forums

Welcome to Aloft Forums. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

" The ubiquitous dB " transmitted power, antenna gain, and all that

I am relatively new to this Forum and have been seeking information about Taranis X9D plus 2019 and the FrSKY RX6R receiver.

Trying to be very graceful in how I say this; a more unified use of "dB" in our discussions would be very helpful.

Wikipedia has a wonderfully detailed page on the subject and shows the small but important differences between terms like dB, dBm, dBw, and a collection of antenna specific units.



An even better description is found in "Introduction to Airborne Radar" George Stimson. There are several different revisions and all are very useful. Besides having an excellent discussion of dB, George does a really good job of describing antenna performance. He uses pictures and drawings to explain the concepts without resorting to trying to describe things with Maxwell's equations, Friis or the like. Early on Hughes published this book and only let employees or their customers have copies. Guess what, antenna performance is really important in radars. George was a proposal manager at Hughes and spent years learning how to explain how their radars worked so customers would buy from Hughes and not someone else. I did not want to copy sections from Georges book out of respect for his great work but it is now widely available for modest prices.

About antennas: Antennas are passive devices and thus do not ever transmit more power than they're given. Gain (and directivity) are measures of the pattern shape and the ability to focus power in a particular direction, hence to often cited positive numbers of gain. dB units are almost (almost, almost ) always used to describe antennas. Positive gain numbers do not imply that more power is radiated than delivered. In the context here, the characteristics do not change if an antenna is used to transmit or receive. Another important measurement relates to how much of the power delivered to the antenna is actually absorbed to be radiated. Various terms are used to describe this including VSWR, reflection coefficient, s11, matching and the like. The idea is that good antennas do not reflect much of the delivered power. Bad antennas do reflect power and thus little is left to radiate. A good match (low reflection) is necessary for good antenna performance but it does not guarantee that the antenna will be useful. A -10 dB attenuator has a good match for example but it is a rotten antenna. Antenna matching is hardly ever mentioned here. By the way, two or more of those metal things are antennas, antennae are two or more long pointy things one finds on cockroaches. At least, that is the common usage in American English. British English journals do not always use the same convention.

Those little connectors used on the models, Hirose U.Fl, and the like are very fragile and wear out after a small number of mate and break cycles. Handle them carefully and infrequently.
 
Love the cockroach reference.

This is not a technical journal but rather a layman's forum. Also as english is a second language for many of us. You are likely to see a lot of spelling and grammatical errors here on this world wide forum.

That term "gain" will be giving us fits for as long as no technical folks are with us. So will the logarithmic scale.

All the best,
Konrad
 
Hi Konrad,

I figured that you might comment. The cockroach choice was done with malice and forethought. Nothing accidental there.

A dB ruler differs from the rulers and measurements normally used, in that it compresses big values and expands small ones. To make matters even harder to understand, a +3 dB change from +30 dBm is much bigger than a +3 dB change from -30 dBm. In the RF world that is convenient because of the wide ranges in the things that are measured. That dB ruler takes some work to use comfortably. It can be used as to compare two values (dB) or compare to some specific reference (dBm, dBc, dBi, etc.). The understanding is often daunting. Gain in an amplifier implies that the RF output level is more than the RF input. In an antenna the output power is always less than the input power, even if the antenna gain is positive. If that were not the case we would have a perpetual motion machine. If I could do that and patent it I would be incredibly rich because I could provide free power. I would suggest that anyone playing around here has to have a significant degree of technical skill.

dB is a logarithmic scale. It varies a bit when voltage is being discussed rather than power. Learn to use dB and it will set one free. It has the added benefit of allowing us to torment anyone who has not been initiated and grasped the concepts. English speakers have trouble with English. It does not take a non-native speaker for that to happen.

Hopefully the above post will help to demystify "gain". Wikipedia is technically correct but Stimson is much more interesting to read and actually understand. He also gives some tricks to cheat and really play the game well.
 
Back
Top