What's new
Aloft Forums

Welcome to Aloft Forums. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Spektrum to Frsky electronics swap help

Jseven

New User
Hello, I recently bought a Horizon Hobby Apprentice STS to learn on. I have a Taranis X7 radio and really do not want to buy a Spektrum one as well. Is it easier to swap out the receiver and flight control if need be to use my Taranis or would it be better to get that 4 in 1 module and go that route? I appreciate any feedback, this is my first airplane but I have a lot of experience with building kits. Does anybody know if the newest Taranis transmitter with ACCESS will work with dsmx or dsm2 ?
 
Access and the Spektrum protocols are exclusive to each other.

Why not put a FrSky RX in the Apprentice and be done with Spektrum?
 
Hello, I recently bought a Horizon Hobby Apprentice STS to learn on. I have a Taranis X7 radio and really do not want to buy a Spektrum one as well. Is it easier to swap out the receiver and flight control if need be to use my Taranis or would it be better to get that 4 in 1 module and go that route? I appreciate any feedback, this is my first airplane but I have a lot of experience with building kits. Does anybody know if the newest Taranis transmitter with ACCESS will work with dsmx or dsm2 ?

As Konrad indicated FRsky and Spektrum have different transmission protocols between their transmitter and receivers and so only support FRsky protocols. Yes a MPM would work in your QX7. But since you want to move to FRsky simply purchase one of the many FRsky receivers (RX6R) being a 6 channel receiver ( with no on board Gyro) and swap it out with the Spektrum receiver. You will then have RSSI and if you add it electric flight pack voltage with audio alerts.

Does the Apprentice STS have a stabiliser flight controller, you could consider the Archer SR6 six channel receiver with on board gyro stabilizer. The Archer SR6 is an ACCESS only receiver.

You are about to become an FRsky expert.
 
Access and the Spektrum protocols are exclusive to each other.

Why not put a FrSky RX in the Apprentice and be done with Spektrum?
Hey Konrad, thank you for your response, I actually have a couple extra frysky receivers, the problem is they dont plug in to the Spektrum flight control, I am able to solder but wasnt sure if that is all I would need to do. That would be amazing if it is just a simple swap of receivers , thank you !!
 
As Konrad indicated FRsky and Spektrum have different transmission protocols between their transmitter and receivers and so only support FRsky protocols. Yes a MPM would work in your QX7. But since you want to move to FRsky simply purchase one of the many FRsky receivers (RX6R) being a 6 channel receiver ( with no on board Gyro) and swap it out with the Spektrum receiver. You will then have RSSI and if you add it electric flight pack voltage with audio alerts.

Does the Apprentice STS have a stabiliser flight controller, you could consider the Archer SR6 six channel receiver with on board gyro stabilizer. The Archer SR6 is an ACCESS only receiver.

You are about to become an FRsky expert.
Oh man, I wish, I still get confused with tx and rx . I believe it does have a stabiliser flight control or safe. That is where I get confused, I know I need to replace the Spektrum rx but wouldnt I also have to replace the spektrum flight control as well ? Will the archer replace both ? Sorry for all the questions, i couldnt find anything on google so I really appreciate your help
 
Oh man, I wish, I still get confused with tx and rx . I believe it does have a stabiliser flight control or safe. That is where I get confused, I know I need to replace the Spektrum rx but wouldnt I also have to replace the spektrum flight control as well ? Will the archer replace both ? Sorry for all the questions, i couldnt find anything on google so I really appreciate your help

If it were me, I would return the Apprentice and get another plane that doesn't have a receiver (meaning a PNP / Plug-n-Play) and put in a FrSky receiver and be done with it.

I don't know much about FrSky at all but I can tell you that Spektrum / Horizon Hobby BNF planes just don't play well with other systems and you are probably not going to have a good time getting it to work with your current transmitter.

Part of the reason the Apprentice is so expensive is because it has those features that pretty much ONLY work with spektrum transmitters.

Motion RC has some PNP planes here and a couple of them look like high-wing trainers similar to the apprentice:


Or hobby king has some PNF trainers here (the ones with the "pusher" motors and dihedral wings would be good trainers)


Unfortunately Aloft doesn't seem to have a really good trainer.
 
You have three options:

  • Return the plane - get something else. There are probably cheaper trainers out there you can put your receiver in. I would recommend a tail dragger. Something like an old Funcub.
  • Buy the DXe transmitter (~$50 used) that comes with the RTF (ready to fly) version, or trade up from your BNF (Bind and Fly) to RTF ---- you will have AS3X (gyros), Safe (3 modes) and Panic Button (read the manuals - they are online). If you are a beginner, without anyone to guide you thru the flying process take this option.
  • Swap out the receivers - Sell the Spektrum receiver. Have someone help you with the flying initially...
 
...
Unfortunately Aloft doesn't seem to have a really good trainer.
Actually the Slow Stick is one of the best trainers as far as flying speed goes. Because it is a bit fragile it is not the very best. But it is slow and rather easy to repair. And if you want all the bells and whistles you can add a FrSky stabilized Rx and have close to what the big box guys offer at 1/4 the price and not be locked into a crippling restrictive protocol.
 
Last edited:
Actually the Slow Stick is one of the best trainers as far as flying speed goes. Because it is a bit fragile it is not the very best. But it is slow and rather easy to repair. And if you want all the bells and whistles you can add a FrSky stabilized Rx and have close to what the big box guys offer at 1/4 the price and not be locked into a crippling restrictive protocol.

Good to know. Thanks.
 
Just change the receiver for an FRsky one, if you can't return the Apprentice. It will be fine - I have done it. The stabiliser function on the Apprentice is terrible anyway - creates bad habits from day one and you will find yourself wrestling with it. If you are a beginner I would stay away from the FRsky SR (stabilised) range as the setting up process is fairly involved, but check it out first, it is certainly less intrusive than an Apprentice fitted stabiliser

A Bixler 1.1 or similar styled plane would make a good trainer - very tough (even better then the mk2 and mk3 ), has rear facing prop and belly landing so no landing gear or props to break in the event of bad landings or crashes, can be flown very slowly and most importantly parts are very cheap - you can buy a whole replacement plane for the price of an Apprentice motor !

 
Back
Top